The scene: I-135 and I-35 in Oklahoma. I’m cruising down the interstate, the day is getting hot, my lunch is sitting in my stomach trying to figure out what to do, and I’m listening to Christian radio because I need something to grate against. This is where I was when I decided to come up with a single question with which to stop all the Christian radio ranters I heard.
I needed just one single, solitary bit of rhetoric with which to undermine all the posturing, the pomposity, and the smugness so thick you can cut it with a knife.
At first, I thought it would be: “This is an A or B question. You have to choose one over the other. Do you actually care about people, or are you a santimonious asshole?”
But as emotionally satisfying as this question might be, it falls prey to itself. It’s also not doctrinal, and if these jerks are anything, it’s doctrinal.
I listened to one radio call-in that wasn’t really a radio call-in. It’s a guy who’s connected by phone to some other guy on the street somewhere (in this case, Hollywood of all places). His roving phone guy starts chatting up someone on the other end and says something like, “There’s a guy you should talk to… Here…” and hands off the phone. Then the radio guy does some patter and gradually starts trying to convert the hapless passerby to Christianity then and there. Sort of a spiritual bass fishing competition; hook ‘em and keep ‘em.
This is when I developed the question above. It was clear to me that he didn’t actually give a crap about his victims’ circumstance or even the status of their immortal soul. He just wanted the notch on his crucifix. In other words: He didn’t care, he was a sanctimonious asshole.
But I was listening to the way he was corralling these people in. It was with certainties. The certainty that God would punish sinners, the certainty that the only way out of sin is through Jesus…
So I developed the second question, the one that’s much better. The one that separates the love from the sanctimony. And it is this:
Is God mysterious?
If God is mysterious, then everything could change on a dime, as it did numerous times in the Bible. There are two testaments, after all. God is supposed to love you, but He also demanded that His chosen people commit genocide. The only way around these things is that God is mysterious. So is He?
If God is mysterious, then you’re free to love your fellow homo sapien on your own terms. You have no way of knowing for certain whether you’re pleasing God (the loving God who demands genocide). But if God is not mysterious, then your love is limited and proscribed, and you’re not allowed to actually love me, only to be a sanctimonious asshole who wants me to convert so you can selfishly benefit.
Discuss, if you feel like it. ![]()




