August 27, 2003

  • Depression.

    One of the things I've noticed lately about the people around me is that they're depressed. So I’m going to write about depression head on. I’m saying this right now because some of you might not want to read it. Some of you might rather not read a discourse on depression, and some of you might rather not hear what I have to say about depression.

    My ideas about depression are weird, but they’re informed by experience. They haven’t allowed me to climb up out of the feelings of depression, but they have shown me the value of being where and who I am.

    That said...


    Depression is your soul asking you to rethink everything. This is the most important thing about depression, especially a chronic one.

    The realities of depression are equivalent to turning down the stereo so you can hear what the lyrics to the song are.. You know about that? If you turn down the stereo and listen with headphones, the singer’s voice will pop out of the song. The singular and most important part of what you’re hearing stands out like a sore thumb because you’ve turned down all the confusing other stuff, like the guitars and drums and bass. Depression is the same dynamic; it turns down the volume of your life so you can hear the lyrics and know what’s important.

    And recognizing what’s important, and moving toward it, and holding it carefully so you don’t break it.. That’s the real challenge depression makes of you.

    Soulless people don’t get depressed. There’s a popular myth going around lately that we should look at depression as if it were a disease, or an epidemic. I think it’s just the opposite... If people were mentally unhealthy, they wouldn’t get depressed by the craziness of the world. Frequent and prolonged depression that doesn’t come from a physical ailment is a sign that the world around you is nuts. If you have a soul, that is. If you don’t have a soul, then I can’t help you.

    My depression, when I’m inside it, is a result of the constant offset between myself and the world outside. The world will always seem nuts to me, for the same reason that I’m always going to seem nuts to the world. Unfortunately, the question my soul asks in those situations is the wrong question to be asking. My neurology is off just enough that there’s no reconciling me and the world of people. Depression triggered by the nutso world won’t help me find what’s important, because that trigger will always be present.

    But. Be that as it may. In general, and for all people I’ve encountered, the real ‘cure’ for depression is not to cure depression, but to give in to it just enough, quiet your mind enough, give up hope just enough that you can see what’s old and non-workable for what it is, without ending up slitting your wrists or something. It's a careful line to try and walk.

    The problem is that, for many people, the reason they can’t allow themselves to be depressed is the same thing that’s causing them to be depressed. For instance, a hectic job that you really hate might cause you to be depressed, but you can’t allow yourself depression because then you’d lose your job to sick days. What depression is asking you to give up is sometimes the hardest thing to give up.

    And that’s why everyone hates depression. Everyone bad-mouths it, calls it a disease, prescribes little pills to make you not feel it, stuffs it down into themselves in hopes that it’ll go away, grins and bears it, and so forth. There’s no cultural space for depression. It’s like PMS, except worse, because at least PMS is somewhat predictable. Everyone wants their life to work the way they planned it, and how dare depression come along and wreck all that?

    But the truth is that in many cases, depression is your body and/or subconscious mind being wise. They know what they need, and they’ll do what they have to in order to get it. Maybe they need for you to sit around and do nothing for a week while they rest, or get used to something new. Maybe they need for you to feel the hard things you’ve been trying not to feel. Maybe they need for you to figure out that living with your parents is the wrong thing to be doing.

    I’m thinking about something I heard about a while back: Menstrual huts. The idea being that women who were on their moon, as they say, would go off and do work in the village menstrual hut. A sort of retreat for menstruating women, so they can work out what they need to work out, and the rest of the village doesn’t grow to hate them while they do it. After the period is over, they go back and resume their previous role in the community.

    Depression should serve a similar purpose, and be an opportunity to re-evaluate the life one is leading, to determine whether you’re doing the wrong thing, or the right thing in the wrong situation. The difference being that you might not come back and serve the same role in the community.

    Depressing thought, huh?

Comments (8)

  • Heh. I know you're right. However, I *do* take little pills and I'm STILL nearly disabled by this. I guess maybe I have TWO souls or somethin'...

    I'm just really sick and tired of being sick and tired.

  • Been reading about the bad side effects of SSRIs (i think that's the right thing) of those little pills. That includes zoloft, paxil and prozac. Dont go off them if you're on them. Not without your doctor's guiding hand. It seems like they may cause some SERIOUSLY dangerous side effects it has to do with the half-life of the pills in the system. Seems that the faster the chemical leaves the system the harder and faster the side effects can come on. the fastest is Paxil, then Zoloft, then Prozac... that's most dangerousn to least...

    If anyone reading this on any of these drugs finds themselves has violent reactions to them you need to TALK TO YOUR DOCTOR.

    The pharmecutical companies are using every dollar they have to make these drugs seem like the only cure...and they arnt a cure. The doctors are given crates of free samples to hand out. It's very easy for people to think that a sample is safe to take and then decide to go off by themselves... I watched some one do this...

    I've also watched someone who was very dependant on Zoloft. when he couldnt get his refills on time he became a screaming yelling tyrant. And he had two small children. His wife eventually had to take the kids and leave.

    Go take a look at the info out there about the hazards of these drugs. It's eye opening.

    I'm not saying that it doesnt help in extreme cases, but the huge numbers of people who are taking them to cope with things that actually should require some changes in their lives...

    Wonder what percentage of the population will have to get put on these things before we collectively snap to the idea that our common way of life isnt working?

    ok. so, I'll get off my rant box now.
    nuffsed 53

  • the best thing my mother ever did for me as a teenager was to refuse me anti-depressants.

    anyway, I completely dig what you are saying, even though sometimes I beg my therapist for something, anything to help me get out of the pain.  she's a good therapist she says "Let's talk about this next time" and I'm still meds free.

  • [i]Depression is your soul asking you to rethink everything. This is the most important thing about depression, especially a chronic one.[/i]

    Wow, that is deep shit. I think you articulated in this one post what I've been trying to formulate the words for, for a while now.

    Thanks.

  • As my girlfriend is bi-polar I have some intimate familiarity with deep depression and have a definitely different view of it. 

    As for the pills....  Were it not for her lithium and other meds she would not be alive today, period.

  • Bi-polar is a different kettle of fish altogether. Different causes, different methods of coping.

  • Good point. It's like listening to your fears.  Using your weaknesses to enhance your strengths, etc.

  • we are handled pills to fix problems with our lives. standard treat the symptoms not the disease modern medicine.

    i got myself out of depression tooth and nail. a long hard slog. and some days i go back for a swim, but i now know where the path out is.

    the things i learned doing that are priceless to me. i've discovered i'm a hell of a lot stronger than i ever imagined.

    i recently remembered where i heard the depression= accuracy study tidbit- from my sister the cognitive scientist.

Comments are closed.

Post a Comment